Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Why Did I Hide My I-Pod During the Stop-over in Dakar?

I pulled the complementary gold-striped red blanket closer and shivered in the fake cold. It was midnight local time, 2 AM according to my biological clock and 7 PM back home. Outside the tiny portal windows I could see the halted construction of the Dakar airport.

The stewardess came on the loud speaker to let us know ground crew members would be coming onto the flight to perform a security check and clean the cabin. We would be departing in one hour. I took out my I-Pod and selected Jackson Browne’s Running on Empty in celebration of my 40 plus hours of travel from Botswana, where I had been studying abroad for four months, back to my home in Minneapolis.

A crew wearing blue vests, speaking to each other in French and Wolof, swarmed onto the plane. They called to each across the aisles as they vacuumed the floors and patted down empty seats in an attempt to find explosives. One with a garbage bag walked passed my aisle seat, and I silently slipped my I-Pod underneath my blanket.

Immediately, I was ashamed. I like to think of my self as a liberal person, or at least rational, but this quick concealment was surely one of bigotry, the result of a newly-discovered racism that made me instinctively hide my valuables whenever poor black people were around. The perspective gained after spending a semester away from the American mindset had already began to fade. No one noticed my act of prejudice, especially the ground crew, but it didn’t matter. With a movement of my wrist, I revealed my true nature.

I recognized the error and absurdity of my ways, yet I kept the I-Pod under my blanket. The reasons behind my action became more complex. Even if I was inherently distrustful of those around me, I knew there was no way someone could steal it from my lap, get past the others patting down headrests in search of liquid nitrogen, and make it onto the tarmac with the freedom to listen to my 15 gigabytes of music.

Maybe, I thought, I hid it not for my benefit, but for theirs. In Botswana, I had seen Western culture permeated throughout every facet of life. I talked to people about how their way of life was fading, replaced by something foreign to them, something they could not understand. I saw the collective identity of the Batswana being crushed by the shear weight of American influence. Some accepted it readily, for its association with prosperity, contrasted to the poverty around them, but that did not make the destruction of Tswana culture any easier to bear or witness.

I had never been to Senegal before my one-hour stop over in Dakar, so I don’t know if it’s similar to Botswana, but maybe, I thought, I hid my I-Pod not because of a racist instinct, but because I wanted to keep the Western influence out of Senegal a little bit longer. It was just a small something I could do to help stop my culture from extending further, into places it didn’t belong.

This was the real reason, I thought. Of course I’m not a racist. I settled back into my seat and tried to get some sleep. But my wondering continued. The explanation of my action as an attempt to stop Western hegemony may be a nobler cause than bigotry, but still just as ignorant. Most likely, the ground crew already had I-Pods nicer than my own. And why not? If I can listen to an I-Pod, why can’t the Dakar ground crew have the same opportunity, even if it comes from outside their society? One of the few positive realities of globalization is the sharing of ideas and technology that occurs between countries.

The biggest problem that I saw in Botswana with outside influences was not necessarily the influences themselves, but the pace at which they entered into society. It seemed as if Western culture and Western capitalist development had been dropped right on top of that landlocked, arid country, leaving its citizens scrambling to make sense of it all. While trying to figure out what to it all meant, what was useful, what was not, their culture was slowly breaking apart in pieces. By hiding my I-Pod, I was just trying, in a small way, to give the Senegalese some time to make up their minds about all that globalization offered.

Again, a nice and noble explanation, but still slightly misguided. It’s like the Coke bottle in the movie, The Gods Must Be Crazy, and the confused San people who fight over its purpose, no one really understanding what it is. That story line is now outdated. When I visited the San, they had Coke bottles, and they were drinking from them. Africans are not as blinded by the light as some like to think, they understand what is going on. Some might not like what the West is doing to their culture, but that doesn’t mean they cannot enjoy Coke or listen to an I-Pod.

Development is quickly becoming focused on the individual, with microcredit and capacity building programs emerging as the most successful. Capacity building is all about giving people the option to help themselves, to make their own choices. If they want to listen to an I-Pod, I shouldn’t stop them. If they like parts of Western culture, then we shouldn’t deter that assimilation. But the problem arises when Western culture and Western development is not a choice, but something forced. That is how cultural displacement occurs. It is a fine line between forcing culture on someone and letting them pick and choose what they want to absorb. My short four months in only one African country is not enough time to figure out where that line is drawn. It exists, and finding out where is what successful development should focus on.

Eventually, I gave up my wondering, leaving the I-Pod underneath the blanket to weigh down my lap with all its complexities. Its questions would remain with me for the duration of my 40 hour journey, and probably continue to turn up whenever my thoughts went beyond American borders. After slightly overstaying their promised one hour, the ground crew left the plane and I, still not knowing why, removed my I-Pod from its hiding spot. We departed westward.

Friday, April 11, 2008

The Final Adventures

The last month has gone by quick. I’m now left with two weeks in Gaborone, a week of classes and a week of finals. I sometimes get moments of realization that my study abroad experience is almost over and it’s hard to believe. I still feel like I just got here.

March was full of adventures, probably the reason it went by so quickly. My group took a weekend trip to Johannesburg, South Africa, the first time we had been out of the country all semester, and it was an experience, to say the least. After we crossed the border, and I began to watch the South African landscape unfold before me, I wondered how such a beautiful country could once support such a brutal and oppressive government.

Most of our time in Johannesburg was spent learning about its history. We visited the Apartheid Museum, which was one of the most intense three hours of my life, as well as the site of the student uprisings in Soweto. The same street that the first students were shot for protesting against the Apartheid government is the same street that Nelson Mandela and Archbishop Desmond Tutu lived on. I could feel the history coming off the pavement.

I think my whole experience in South Africa can be summed up by something my professor, who did her doctorate in South Africa, said to me over lunch. We were at a McDonald’s, and I commented on how much razor wire was up all over the city. She replied “This country invented razor wire.” After spending two days immersed in its history, I couldn’t argue.

The following weekend, some of us took a trip west to the Kalahari Desert to a town named Ghanzi. This region of the Kalahari is the home of the tribe the Tswana call the Basarwa, also known as the Bushmen or the San. The Botswana government is currently in a legal battle with the San after forcing them to relocate several different times off their lands, and many human rights NGOs have formed in the region to help resist the oppression of the San. We went to a museum about San culture in the village of D’Kar, where many San have been relocated to, some through force. D’Kar was described to me as a “big refugee camp” by a Fulbright scholar here studying cultural tourism and the San.

Besides the museum, we also went on a guided bushwalk in the Dqãe Qare Game Farm (pronounced with several clicks), owned by the tribe of Ncoakhoe (also pronounced with several clicks.) This game farm is actually now the only lands the San can live on in their traditional hunter-gather way, and the Batswana government only allows this because the game farm was a gift to the Ncoakhoe from the Dutch government.

However, only the staff of the Dqãe Qare lives on the farm, and none practice hunting or gathering. Mostly it serves to house tourists, although it does host cultural events put on by the San community. We went on a guided bushwalk with the Ncoakhoe, where we followed around an old woman with a big stick, who would point to different plants, say something in Naro (the language of the Ncoakhoe) and then wait for another one of our guides to translate for us. We learned about lots of different medicines, tried a desert potato and a Bushman salad, and learned about how the San find water in the dry season. (They burry empty ostrich egg shells filled with water during the wet season and come back when they can’t find other sources of water.)

Another exciting event was our private meeting with former President Masire. Masire was president of Botswana from 1980-1998 and wrote an autobiography with the help of a former president of Carleton, which is how ACM was able to arrange our meeting. In his retirement, Masire does a lot of peacekeeping work and the most interesting part of the dinner was talking with his personal secretary. They had just been in Kenya, trying to stop the post-election violence and form an agreement between Odinga and Kibaki. They also were recently in Rwanda, and it was incredible to hear about the continuing impact of the genocide.

I also got to watch two Botswana national soccer games, one against Zimbabwe and one against a club team from Brazil. They lost both times, but it was still entertaining to watch. This week, we went to the Jwaneng diamond mind, one of three in Botswana and the wealthiest in the world, something my Motswana roommate referred to as “our lifeblood.” Botswana has used much of its diamond revenues for good, like free universal education and healthcare, so I can understand why my roommate referred to it in that way. To me, it looked like a big hole in the ground.

Now, as I end my third to last week in Gaborone, I cannot believe all my adventures are coming to an end. I still have one last big trip to go, after finals. Three other Grinnellians and I are going up to Victoria Falls for a week, and then over to the Namibian coast for another week, then I’ll head back to Grinnell for Blockparty and graduation. If all goes well, I’ll be spending my 21st birthday on the shores of the Chobe River, on the border between Botswana, Namibia, Zambia and Zimbabwe. It’ll be a great end to a wonderful semester abroad.

Tuesday, March 4, 2008

My First Safari

The saddest part of my semester abroad was probably last Sunday night, driving from the Sir Seretse Khama airport into Gaborone. I had just spent a week up north in the Okavango Delta and the Kalahari Desert, and as I entered the city, it seemed like all the modern conveniences and achievements passing by me could not compare with all the things I had just experienced and seen.

The first night of my safari was spent in the Okavango Delta, the only inland delta in the world. We camped out in what was, in simplest terms, the “bush.” To get to our campsite, a dozen natives of the area piled me and the rest of my fellow travelers into mokoros, traditional canoes made by hollowing out tree trunks. (Later, I saw one of the trees used to make these, it does not seem like an easy task.) Two people fit into one mokoro, along with one standing poler in the back, who somehow navigated through the thick reeds that made it impossible to see anything in front of us.

Right before we reached out campsite, we started to hear grunting noises coming from very close by. The guide on my mokoro did not speak much English, but he was able to come up with “hippo,” as we looked frantically through the reeds. Thankfully, we never got close enough to see what it looked like—hippos are very territorial and cause most of the animal-on-human deaths in Africa—but we did hear it grunting throughout the night.

Luckily, I was able to see hippos from much farther away on the second part of my safari, in the Kalahari Desert. The first few nights we stayed at the Nxai Salt Pans, one part of the Kalahari, which is basically like an ocean with no water. They have almost no animals in them, because all of the salt makes the water there undrinkable. After dark, I was able to see the stars clearer than I had ever before, with the illuminating Milky Way going over my head from one horizon to the next, cutting the night sky in half.

Most of the time in the Kalahari was taken up with the ever-present “game runs.” These consisted of sitting in the back of an open-air truck, driving for eight to ten hours a day. Not exactly up to caliber with Hemingway or Kipling. Surprisingly, it was exhausting, bumping up and down on the dirt paths of the savannah. And worth it, I was able to see cheetahs, lions, hippos, elephants, and any type of antelope you could think of, some I didn’t even know existed.

The best part was that I got to see most of these animals close enough that they could have killed me if they wanted to. I did not know the power of a lion until I looked up through the windshield of my safari truck and saw one staring me in the face. I didn’t know how dangerous an elephant could be until one crossed the road about ten meters in front of the truck and turned to look at us, head on. For a split second, I thought that my life would end underneath the remains of a beige four-wheel drive, but instead of charging us, the elephant got scared, quickly turned and ran away faster than I thought an animal of that size could run.

The last night we stayed in the Makgadikgadi National Park, another part of the Kalahari. We camped on a cliff looking over a now-dried-up river, and as soon as I saw the view our site provided, I considered jumping over the cliff and living in one of the trees with the monkeys for the rest of my life. I then realized that I probably would die after four days on my own, so instead I just continued to look. The only thing I could see was miles and miles of savannah, miles and miles of trees and animals and birds and everything else I had experienced in the last week of my life. I watched thunderstorms roll over the landscape as the sun set, and my friends and I left only when we were told the lions would be coming out soon and we needed to get back into the protection of the main campsite.

It’s hard to think about my week long safari, because I know I won’t be back there for a while, if ever. It was an incredible experience, going to a place I didn’t even know existed six months ago and most people still don’t know exists. I hope that one day I will be able to return, somehow.

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Traveling Around

Exploring the city of Gaborone in my first weeks made me forget sometimes I had left North America for Africa, which provided a very easy transition for the other Americans on my program and me. I began to think that maybe our American culture had just been transplanted to this foreign land without any of us knowing. But as I traveled around the country more, I started to see past my first impressions and began to realize what kind of country Botswana really is.

Since I am only in the country for a semester, I am trying to see as much of it as possible. The social life on the University campus is not that exciting, so I and the other students on the program have been going on a lot of weekend trips.

The first one we took was to a place called Serowe. Technically it is still a village, but it is the largest village in Southern Africa. I don’t know what makes a village a village, but this place was definitely not a city. There were goats all over the place, and we almost hit a few. The cars didn’t slow down and stop for them; they just honked loudly and hoped they’d get out of the way. There was a central area with a shopping center, but it was mostly traditional houses sprawled out all over the place. After arriving, walking through the bus rank to find a ride to where we were staying was really the first time I was complete aware of my different skin color. I know they had seen white people before, but after eight got off the bus, looking lost and confused, everyone swarmed around, trying to offer us a ride. One vendor woman just straight up asked us: “Where’s my money?”

In Serowe, we stayed in a place called Khama Rhino Sanctuary, home to thirty white rhinos and two black rhinos, as well as thousands of other animals. When I say we stayed in it, I mean we actually slept inside the park. We had to be driven around by a guide whenever we wanted to go somewhere, because it is very easy to come across a rhino or a leopard. We went on a game run while there, and it was probably the most amazing thing I have done so far, and probably one of the most amazing things I have ever done. For lack of a better simile, it was like living in The Lion King. We saw rhinos, zebras, ostriches, antelopes and a whole bunch of other animals I had never heard of.

That night, I broke the rules and walked a little ways away from the designated “camp” with some friends to an old wooden look-out post we had found earlier. It was rotting and shaky, but I was able to climb to the top to watch the sun set over the savannah. I hope I never forget what that looked like.

Last weekend, we went on another trip to a place called Molepolole. This is closer to Gaborone, and we only spent a day there, but it was still quite an adventure. We visited a cave that was believed to hold evil spirits, until David Livingstone spent a night in it and proved the local chief wrong. It smelled like bat poop and we met a Rasta-man on the way up smoking a joint out of a twenty Pula (the local currency) note who told us he was going “to kill the dragon.” After that we tried to find the ruins of the old London Missionary Society (which no one, except Lonely Planet, had ever heard of) and then the aloe forest (which no one had heard of until we described it as “the forest that scared the Boers away,” a local legend about the Boers invasion.) Once we arrived in the aloe forest, we met either a drunk or crazy—or both—woman who made us try the aloe plant, calling it the “number one medicine.” I almost threw up.

I know when I first came to Botswana, I was surprised at the level of development and influence of American culture in this country—and I still am. (In Molepolole, we got a ride from a combi that had two television screens in it, playing Shania Twain and Celine Dion music videos.) But I have also realized that this is still a Third World country. A lot of the development, it seems to me, is really just on the surface. There is not much infrastructure. For example, Botswana has not been developing its own power sector, because it could always import cheaper electricity from South Africa. Now, South Africa is facing a power crisis and has cut off Botswana. The power now frequently shuts off without warning, along with the hot water, something even the locals get mad about.

Another good example, which I’ve been thinking of as a microcosm of the whole nation, is the pool they have on campus. It is Olympic-sized, and during orientation they made a point of mentioning it as a source of pride for the campus. I was excited to start swimming in it, as it gets unbearably hot here in the afternoon, but so far I’ve swam in it only once, the first week of school. Although I’ve gone almost every day since I’ve been here, it has always been “dirty.” I don’t know why it’s dirty, but they always tell me it will be clean in a week. Now I’ve stopped asking and I just go right to the smaller, cleaner pool. One other American remarked; “Why would they build an Olympic-sized swimming pool if they couldn’t maintain it?” I think it is a good question, a little presumptuous, but an interesting thought.

It seems like a lot of the things they do here is simply because they can do them. They build malls all over the place because they have the money to and because people want to shop, even though they are still one of the most unequal nations in the world, with huge levels of unemployment. Maybe, as Americans who are used to having things like working pools and large malls, we can have the freedom to critique. Botswana is still a young country, trying to figure out its explosive growth. So far, I think they’re doing a pretty good job, and I have been having a lot of fun, even if I don’t really understand all the time what’s going on around me.

Friday, January 18, 2008

Botswana Travels- part 1

The first two weeks of my semester abroad in Botswana have been full of things that remind me of home. They started in the Johannesburg airport, on the tarmac to our flight to Gaborone, sitting next to an Asian Muslim family as their two-year old sang “The Wheels on the Bus.” We attended a traditional dinner as an introduction to Tswana culture, where we, among other things, played an African game that was basically “Duck Duck Grayduck” along with “London Bridge is Falling Down.” At another traditional dancing performance, one of the dancers slipped on her pair of Crocs as soon as she was finished dancing.

The more time I spend in Gaborone, the capital of Botswana and the largest city, the less these reminders of home begin to seem out of place in an African country, and more like normal occurrences. Coming to this place, I had no preconceptions of the area, and I could not have been more surprised at what I would find. The main thing to do in Gaborone is go to malls. I have never been to so many different malls, so many times in my life. I think I average about one trip to the mall a day, sometimes two trips. Some of these malls are combination strip malls with open-air markets, but most are typical shopping centers you would find back home. The most interesting site so far is the road-side vendors underneath large umbrellas selling candy and food right in the shadow of these massive malls. I have also seen a few cardboard shacks advertising “Hair Cut,” “Car Wash” and even “Defensive Driving School.”

Although there are many things to remind me of home, I have seen things that I would never see in America. We had a traditional dinner the second night we were here, were I tried caterpillar and goat meat. After the dinner, the native women in attendance started to dance and attempted to teach us their songs and dances. Some of the students were more successful than others. We also spent a day at a game reserve not to far from the city, were I saw four elephants, an ostrich, some antelope-like impala, and a whole bunch of giraffes. I have been eating a lot of traditional food from the roadside vendors, which includes a giant bread dumpling, rice, chicken or beef, pumpkin, and a bunch of other stuff I can’t really describe—all for only 12 pula, about two dollars American.

One thing I have not seen a lot of here is poverty. It exists, but it is not as apparent in Gaborone. Botswana is one of the most unequal countries in the world, and with a population of around 1.6 million, most of the wealth in concentrated in the city. I have seen two very very bad shantytowns within city limits, but other than that, most people here seem pretty wealthy. The students on campus dress nicer than any other student body I have ever seen. In the coming weeks, I hope to get out and see more of the country, so I can get a better picture of what it actually means to live in Botswana.

Another thing I haven’t seen is the effects of HIV/AIDS on this country. For those of you who don’t know, Botswana has the highest rate of AIDS prevalence in the whole world, the UN has estimated that around 40% of the population is HIV positive. If I hadn’t known this statistic going into this semester, I probably would not have been able to tell. There are the occasional advertisements on billboards and in newspapers promoting safe sex, as well as free condom dispensers everywhere, although most of the time they are empty. Other than that, and the occasional side comment in conversations, you wouldn’t know the epidemic had spiraled out of control.

I do not know why the AIDS crisis is not so visible here, even though it is a huge problem, and I have been heard conflicting viewpoints about the epidemic in general. My Setswana (the other national language, besides English) teacher told us yesterday that the AIDS epidemic is really not that bad—she actually referred to the crisis in the past tense. Anti-retroviral drugs have been distributed free here since the late 90s, curbing the problem and making it less visibly apparent. She said that the 40% rate is much too high of an estimate, and that it is actually only around 30%. Even if that were true, that would mean about one in three people would have AIDS, better than two in five, but still a huge problem. On the other hand, I’ve also heard that the University of Botswana has the highest AIDS rate in the country, making it the “AIDS capital of the world.” I don’t know which viewpoint is true, but either way, it still is a huge problem.

I have been spending a lot of time with the people on my program, as well as the other Americans here. The University of Botswana has around 40 Americans currently on campus, the most they have ever had. The other 18 students on my program (organized by the Associated Colleges of the Mid-West) are amazing and I couldn’t have asked for a better group of people to spend four months with. I can’t remember the last time I laughed as frequently and as hard as I have been in the last two weeks. Some of us went to an Applebee’s-like restaurant in one of Gaborone’s most popular shopping malls a few weeks ago, and it could have been the three dollar mixed drink, but sitting in that restaurant talking with all of my new friends, I forgot I was in Botswana and thought I was back in the States.

The thing that amazes me the most about my first two weeks here in Gaborone is not the American influence, the giant shopping centers, or even the public transportation, which is basically made up of fifteen person, semi-broken down vans called “combis” that stops whenever and wherever you want, and holds as many people as can be stuffed in. What I find most surprising is the way I fit in here, the way I feel perfectly at home. This could be due to the prevalence of American culture, and if I was European, Asian, or from another African country, I might not feel as comfortable as I do now. I don’t know. But for better or for worse, maybe that’s what globalization is really about; feeling at home wherever you go, even halfway across the world.

It’s also hotter than hell.

Tuesday, January 1, 2008

Botswana Travels

Well, I don't know if anyone still reads this thing, but I just wanted everyone to know that I'm going to be heading out to Botswana this Thursday for a semester abroad and probably won't be posting much on this blog from then until I get back in mid-May. I know I haven't been posting much anyways, but a semester's worth of school work can do that to you.

What I do plan on doing is writing "letters from abroad" and emailing them to my friends and family. This seems like a popular form of communication, and I'll post them on here as well. If you want to be included on this email list, let me know at raderstr@grinnell.edu. I'll have periodic access to email if you want to contact me for any reason, but other than that, I have no idea about other forms of communication.

So, have a good four months and happy new year!

Monday, November 26, 2007

The Evils of Sesame Street

Most of you probably watched Sesame Street growing up. It is one of the longest running shows in television history, as well as one of the longest running experiments in child psychology and education. It was started in 1969 and was one of the first shows to use television to educate children. Last month the first five seasons were released on DVD, and many nostalgic adults eager to share their childhood with their children were shocked to learn that these "early 'Sesame Street' episodes are intended for grown-ups, and may not suit the needs of today's preschool child."

How could that be? Have we really gotten so paranoid that we think ancient Sesame Street episodes could actually hurt preschoolers? Sesame Street has been through many controversies, from Ernie and Bert outed as gays, to the more recent revelation that Cookie Monster could be teaching children obesity. It seems like a sad reflection on society that even Sesame Street needs to be labeled as potentially dangerous to children.

I don't know the reasons the company had to issue this warning, but in their defense, Sesame Street has gone through many changes since its creation. It is constantly going through focus groups to improve its teaching capacity as time changes. The Sesame Street from the first season is much different from the Sesame Street of today, and the older episodes are not designed for children today, but for children of the sixties and the seventies.

However, the PR person that made the decision to put a warning on the Sesame Street DVD probably wasn't thinking about the evolution of the show, only about how overprotected parents might react to the old-school Sesame Street. Apparently, the first episode has a segment with a young girl going home with a strange old man to have some cookies. There is no way the producers could do that today, without lawsuit threats from a number of concerned parents.

This warning label reflects how hyper-concerned our society has become. Sesame Street was created to entertain kids as well as adults, so parents could be engaged in their children's education. Parent reinforcement of education is an important aspect of learning, either real-life or televised. These DVDs give parents the opportunity to tell their kids why they shouldn't go home with strangers, or just eat cookies all the time, even though those things once happened on Sesame Street. The warning label isn't necessary, and parents should be involved enough to teach their kids the difference between right and wrong.

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

Leading by Example

Yes I know my enemies...
Compromise, conformity, assimilation, submission
Ignorance, hypocrisy, brutality, the elite.
All of which are American dreams.
- Zack de la Rocha


It is another sad day in US history. Once again this administration has compromised our morals to a point that makes me wonder if we ever had any.

You may wonder what I'm talking about, and that shows just how far gone this country is. Today, I'm talking about the declaration of emergency rule in Pakistan by General Pervez Musharraf, and the US' decision to continue aid to the country as an ally in the "war on terror." The Bush administration is obviously upset about the numerous suspensions of civil rights in the country, but not enough to do anything about it. Musharraf, who declared the emergency to suppress "terrorism" in the state, did not expect any reaction from senior US officials to his tightening of power over the country, and he didn't get any. This suspension of the Constitution and the firing of the Supreme Court was conveniently made days before the court was to rule on the legitimacy of his recent reelection.

Musharraf knew that the US cares too much about the war on terror to do anything about a attack on democracy in the name of fighting terrorism. “They [the US] would rather have a stable Pakistan — albeit with some restrictive norms — than have more democracy prone to fall in the hands of extremists,” said Tariq Azim Khan, the minister of state for information.

And even though Bush's presidency has been based on the platform of spreading freedom and democracy, the administration has done nothing but encourage Musharraf to loosen his control. Bush will condemn and sanction anti-democratic actions in Myanmar, a country we have nothing invested in, but then less than a month later, allow one of our "allies" to suspend the rights and liberties of its people. How can we expect other countries, like Iraq, to encourage democracy, when we won't even to it ourselves?

Bush's hypocrisy runs deep. I remember the moment I realized what kind of person we had for a president when he nominated Harriet Miers to the supreme court. He used her track record as an "Evangelical Christian" to try to win her support from the Republican party. This is the same president who said: "It's going to be the spread of democracy, itself, that shows folks the importance of separation of church and state." Obviously, democracy hasn't spread too far in this country.

I can continue to blather on about how much I disapprove of what the administration is doing, and how Bush really only cares about stabilizing his own power, and about how Musharraf's actions will only create more terrorism, as well as Bush's actions in Iraq, but this is something we all know. We knew there were no WMD's in Iraq. We knew that Bush was lying to us. We know that they could have gotten Osama bin Landen instead. We know Karl Rove exposed Valarie Plame. We know this because these senior level administrators have no respect for the values that they claim to promote, or for the citizens they claim to represent.

My question is, why isn't anyone doing anything about it?

Sunday, October 28, 2007

Discontentment in the New Gilded Age

All around are the signs of a new Gilded Age, as people are starting to call our present. VH1 has a show called "The Fabulous Life of...", which dives weekly into the extravagance of one celebrity after another. Internet start-ups continue to make more and more money for their founders, some serving the purpose of only rating strangers' attractiveness. Of the 30 riches Americans, most made their fortunes either during the last Gilded Age or before, with the three exceptions being the contemporary billionaires Bill Gates, Warren Buffet and Sam Walton.

But what has this newly re-found extravagance brought the United States? All of our money is not making us happier, we rank 150 out of 178 in the Happy Planet Index. Its income inequality is comparable to Ghana and Turkmenistan. Our popular culture may depict the United States as a glamorous, wonderful place to be, yet it seems that our large, ever increasing incomes leave us wanting more.

And many people are asking themselves why they aren't happy with their large quantities of cash. (To learn more about the lack of contentment among the wealthy, see the NYTimes series "Age of Riches".) And why is this? The easiest answer is something everyone knows: money can't buy you love. But that is too simple. Money cannot buy love, or happiness, but it can buy just about everything else. One of the first things I learned about Economics is that currency is just a proxy for happiness, something to use as a model of utility and not actually utility itself. And although money cannot actual buy the feeling of being happy, I think they should be at least positively correlated.

So why are we not content in this new Gilded Age of glamor and extravagance? Does the income inequality force most of the population out of the celebrations gained by the wealthy? Yet, not even the wealthy are content, and are driven to work to fill up their lives.

And I don't know the answers to those questions. I have not seen enough of America, or talked with diverse enough amounts of people to determine what is plaguing our nation, if anything is at all. Are we morally bankrupt? Has our culture been hijacked by a small group of corporate executives? Is it really the end of history, and have we forgotten we once had one?

I do think that many people in this country have forgotten the common sense maxim of money cannot buy love. Accumulation of currency does not equate to instant satisfaction, though that is what I expect most people assume, even if they won't admit it. What does actually create happiness is something much more complicated and something people cannot leave up to their bank accounts to determine.

Saturday, October 13, 2007

Making History

I often like to think of what events in my life will be remembered in years to come. When 9/11 happened, I think I began to grasp what kind of time I was growing into, what things the world would face as I started to face the world.

I have always been optimistic, trying to find good even though this country continues to disappoint me. Lately it has been hard. Instead of coming together to try to fix a broken health care system, Republicans and Democrats are fighting amongst themselves, each one not trying to be seen as Socialist. The problems in Iraq are surmounting, beyond repair, yet we continue to stay in it. The Democrats are allowing the wiretapping of Americans, trying not to be seen as "soft on terror."

Last year, when the Democrats took control of Congress, America, to the best of its abilities, was trying to send a message. We do not like the way things are going. And we still don't. Recent Gallup polls show a 32% approval rating for Bush, and a even lower 23% approval rating for Congress. For some reason, Democrats and Republicans are still fighting amongst themselves, trying to gain our approval, and obviously failing.

The case of the recent veto of an expansion of the State Children's Health Insurance Program (S-CHIP), and the Democratic response is a perfect example of how politicians only care about their personal perception. One Democratic ad attacks incumbent Representative H. James Saxton of New Jersey: “Did you know Congressman Saxton gets health care at taxpayers’ expense, but Saxton and Bush are blocking health care for 10 million children? Tell Jim Saxton to put families first.” The Democrats used Graeme Frost, a 12-year old suffering from brain injury, to issue their rebuttal to Bush's veto of the program. Republicans responded by undercutting Frost and his family, and accusing them of exploiting a young boy for political gains. (To see a pretty awful, but informative, run-down of the tearing apart of the Frost family, read conservative Michelle Malkin's blog.)

Instead of working together, our two-party system is fighting against themselves, not realizing they're destroying each other and bringing their country down with them. I no longer have faith in this political system, because those in charge of it only care about their own credibility and not about making this country a better place. If our leaders do not worry about those they govern, what makes them leaders? They may say that they are concerned about what the average American citizen thinks, but, as shown by their approval rating, they do not have the courage to try and make a difference. Attempts at change will always bring failure with it, but our leaders refuse to subject themselves to the potential for failure, and therefore, the potential for change.

I cannot have faith in a system that not only refuses to learn from failure, but actively denies it. We are no longer the greatest country in the world, if we ever truly were. I am still optimistic about what history will say about my generation, but I no longer care what it will have to say about the American political system. If our political leaders do not care about my generation, then I do not care about them.

Thursday, October 4, 2007

The Trade-off for Eritrea

Isolationism is a big buzz word when it comes to international relations, as is dependency. When talking about developing countries, it seems as if these two concepts work as mutually exclusive events. If a country does not want to be completely dependent on richer countries for aid and support, then they must close down their borders.

Eritrea is one such country. This year alone, it has rejected over $200 million in food aid and loans. This East African nation has had the same leader since independence in 1993, Isaias Afwerki, who spearheads their isolationist stance.

Afwerki's words are very inspiring, and he talks of making his country "stand on its own two feet." Afwerki, in a LA Times interview, explained his policies by saying:
Self-reliance is perceived as isolationist. But self-reliance is a means, not an end. It's a means of taking you to the bigger market and the biggest markets. How can I do that with handouts?


The results of these policies are mixed. Eritrea provides free education and health care, and it has higher scores on health indicators than most countries. But Afwerki has jailed people opposing him and restricted religion. He has canceled elections twice and has called those he jailed "crooks" and Eritrea's liberal constitution only a "paper."

Eritrea is a perfect example of the trade-offs between isolationism and opened borders. Although Afwerki may be trying to decrease their dependency on foreign aid and hegemonic powers, he is cutting them off from the rest of the world. By leaving no room for opposition or outside influence, he is stifling the country, economically and socially. Eritrea's growth rate is 2% annually, ranked 179 out of 205.

The international community does not help to make a distinction from "self-reliance" and "isolationist" that Afwerki talks about. If a country refuses aid, or neglects to remove tariffs, it is branded "isolationist" or "totalitarian", and their rulers are seen as insane. There are obvious civil rights abuses in Eritrea and countries similar to it (like North Korea), but that does not mean isolationist policies are inherently bad. There also doesn't have to be such a wide discrepancy between the extremes of dependency and isolationist. There can be a middle ground, with some protection and some free trade.

With some amount of protection, countries can develop their own domestic markets and eventually "stand on their own two feet." After this, they can actively participate in the global economy. Third World countries will never break away from the cycle of aid unless they start to develop themselves. As Afwerki says: "You can't keep these people living on handouts because that doesn't change their lives."

Thursday, September 27, 2007

ONE has lost its way

I'm taking a few minutes out of my day today to help stop global poverty. I just was forwarded an email from Susan McCue at the One Campaign inviting me to join the "ONE Campus Challenge". I signed Grinnell College up, and now anyone on campus can win points for Grinnell by participating in poverty fighting activities, such as dressing up a pet up in ONE gear, getting its marching band to form the "ONE" logo, or getting other people to join in on the Campus Challenge. I decided to start right away, and for this blog post linking to the Campus Challenge, I'm earning 75 points for Grinnell. I hope it will help us get out of 491st place.

A lot of ONE's activities deal with engagement, and because they seem to be reaching people who wouldn't normally know about global poverty, I have been able to ignore Jeffrey Sachs parading around Africa with Angelina Jolie. Even though they offer great prizes to the school that earns the most points, including a prize that's so great it's still a secret, the Campus Challenge doesn't seem to accomplish anything but get more involved with the Campus Challenge.

And that is my major criticism with the ONE Campaign. It is all about increasing awareness, which is fine, but it doesn't offer any information about how to work on the issues after people become engaged. On the main site for the ONE Campus Challenge, the only information it offers besides the rules of the Challenge is that "our generation has the tools, technology, and resources to end extreme poverty and yet, a billion people still live on less than a dollar a day." The ONE main website has an "issues" page, as well as a "take action" page, but the action either involves wearing ONE gear, getting more people to sign up onto ONE, or contacting Congress. (To be fair, the Campus Challenge also asks students to lobby Congress.) When you decide to "learn how to become an active member of the movement," all that is suggested is more ways to engage more people.

It seems like ONE gives people an easy way out for global poverty. It offers people shirts and wristbands, and people can proudly wear these, saying: "I care about global poverty." Which is great. But that care and concern, even if it is well meaning, cannot make change by itself. The ONE campaign offers no real course of action for individuals, it just puts the power back into the hands of politicians and bureaucrats.

And it is daunting for individuals to try to confront poverty by themselves. That is why ONE has gain popularity through uniting many different concerned individuals. But they have lost their way. They have become self-serving and do not look for effective ways to stop poverty, and instead focus on what they think is right rather than what is working.

So what is working? I will shamelessly plug my own student group, the Social Entrepreneurs of Grinnell. We have raised over $3,000 on campus and loaned almost all of it all over the world to Third World entrepreneurs. There is no reason why other colleges can't do this instead of participating in the Campus Challenge.

I think that the work of SEG is more effective than anything the Campus Challenge can accomplish, but are they really ending poverty? Maybe. I don't know. But SEG is actually doing something. And we certainly are doing more to end poverty than just wearing a ONE wristband.

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Update: The Shifting of Terrorism

The Defense Department has developed a new tactic for killing enemy combatants, where snipers place fake weapons or bomb materials and wait for someone to pick it up. Then, they shoot, sometimes to wound and sometimes to kill. Currently, three snipers are on trial for murder charges, and this program, called "baiting", was disclosed in their defense. The Army denies that this is an institutional program, yet many soldiers have testified to its existence.

This just another example of how the U.S. is no longer fighting terrorism, but causing it.

Sunday, September 23, 2007

The Shifting of Terrorism

The war on terror has come full circle. The US was once liberators and now we are the terrorists.

Last Sunday, a convoy of hired Blackwater USA security forces escorting State Department vehicles open fired on a crowd of innocent Iraqis in an open square. The first person they shot was a man in a car, the second was the woman next to him, holding a baby. When the incident was over, somewhere from eight to eleven Iraqis were killed.

The Iraqi government recently released a preliminary report about these events, stating that “the murder of citizens in cold blood in the Nisour area by Blackwater is considered a terrorist action against civilians just like any other terrorist operation."

This statement sums up the US's involvement in Iraqi, military or private. Before, even if it was under false pretenses, the US claimed it was trying to spread freedom and democracy. Now, it seems, we are just adding to the terror we came to stop.

According to Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki, there have been seven incidents of Blackwater needlessly killing Iraqis. Blackwater claims that the convoy they were guarding was ambused, and no press releases or acknowledgment of the issues appears on their web page. The only thing that appears is their denial that employees have been illegally smuggling weapons into Iraq that end up on the black market.

Even before the shootings last Sunday, Iraqi officials repeatedly complained to the US about the problems with Blackwater. After the incident, the Iraqi government banned Blackwater operations. Prime Minister al-Maliki even insisted that the state department drop them as a contractor. But they continued their work anyways. Apparently, private security firms are protected in a loophole law that was set up before the Iraqis took power.

The arrogance of Blackwater's continuation is incredibly frustrating. The US is over in Iraq to stop terrorism, yet we are perpetuating it ourselves. Blackwater has denied all wrongdoings, and the US government has made no moves to evaluate the situation. This situation shows how much we don't care about the Iraqi citizens and just how concerned we are with our own agenda. This isn't the war on terror, and it never has been. Soon, both the American people and the Iraqi people are going to completely realize the falsity of this war and everyone will be in a huge amount of trouble. It seems like it is already to late to do anything about it.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

At Least Two Sides to Every Issue

All of my course work is starting to blend together. I can't remember which conservations I had in which class, which professor said what.

I suppose it's my own fault for choosing classes that try to explain the same thing, just through different academic lenses. But the higher up I get in academia, the more I realize that it doesn't matter whether or not your trying to find answers through political science, ecology or anthropology, people will conclude different things, even while looking at the same facts.

We just read two pieces in my African cultures class, both put out around the same time, but with completely messages. The first was Robert Kaplan's, "The Coming Anarchy" and the other was Nelson Mandela's 1994 speech to the OAU. Both came out around the same time, Kaplan's in February and Mandela's in June, but each describes Africa in a completely different way. Kaplan's article, from the Atlantic Monthly, is famous for being the first wake-up call to the Western world about the trouble Africa is in. After I read it, I felt that Africa is beyond repair and there's nothing we really can do about it.

Mandela comes to a completely different conclusion. He tells the OAU that Africa has been through hard times, but they can persevere through them. He cites South Africa's expulsion of Apartheid as an example of all they can accomplish. Strangely, Mandela's hopeful speech comes after the Rwandan genocide and Kaplan's warning comes only a few months before it. Of course, Mandela is a politician and Kaplan is a journalist.

Another great example of people looking at the same thing but seeing it differently is the Jeffrey Sachs/ William Easterly debate. We're reading both their books ("End of Poverty" and "White Man's Burden", respectively) in Political Economies of Developing Countries, and it is hard to tell which has their facts right. It seems that both of them do, yet their conclusions are such polar opposites.

If you don't know the story behind Sachs and Easterly, Sachs runs the One Campaign with Bono and champions the idea that extreme poverty can be ended by 2025. Easterly makes no such claim and thinks poverty only can be ended by grassroots movements, instead of large aid donations recommended by One. Both make convincing arguments.

But when all the arguing is over, it seems like not much is really getting done. We get reports of terrorism around the world and people dying needlessly. The One Campaign reports 10 million children die every year, mostly from preventable diseases.

That is, until this year. UNICEF today released a report saying that in 2005 the number of child deaths before the age of five dropped to 9.7 million, a fall of 29% from 2000. This is the lowest its been since UNICEF began to record these statistics. "We feel we’re at a tipping point now,” said Dr. Peter Salama, Unicef’s chief medical officer. They expect this drop to continue, and think the UN Development Goal of cutting child mortality by two-thirds by 2025 could be accomplished.

So was Sachs right? Does this drop come from the increased efforts of NGOs like One and the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria? Or was Easterly right, and this reduction in needless deaths is due to people at the bottom finally taking control of their lives?

Was Mandela right in calling Africa to unite and be strong? Or was Kaplan right in scaring the First World into doing something?

If more than 300,000 children are no longer dying needlessly, I don't think it matters.

Monday, September 3, 2007

Read This Post

I am not going to start off with a personal anecdote and suspend for once my delusions that this blog could be a jumping point my my New-York-Times-columnist career.

I am just going to say; read this article: "A Way Out of Debt By Way of Iraq."

It is about the men and women of this country that have chosen to go to Iraq to escape and eliminate their financial burdens.

At first, I thought, how interesting. Then, as I continued to read, I thought, how incredibly horrible and frightening. The article describes how people with massive amounts of debt find volunteering for Iraq an easy way to gain some quick cash and live in a low-cost lifestyle.

My country has left people with no choice but to sell their lives to escape their problems at home. I cannot believe this. I thought this was the land of opportunity, yet my fellow citizens are resorting to participating in warfare and violence to solve their individual problems, and financial ones at that.

I am reminded of a David Cross joke of him describing his reaction to watching a reality show: "Bush always says; 'the terrorists hate our freedom.' Well, I hate our freedom too, if this is what we do with it."

This is the land of the free, but these free people have been forced to resorting to risking their lives abroad to fix their lives at home. If this is what our freedom gets us, then it really isn't freedom.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

In (sort of) Defense of Sweatshops

Today was the first day of classes, and my Econometrics professor started the term off with a NYT's letter to the editor, responding to a report on an econometric study that can determine the quality of a wine without any more data than the weather reports from the year.

Basically, the letter to the editor said that wine quality is too difficult to be determined by an economist, who are all cold and out of touch with reality. My class lamented together for a moment, thinking of all the persecution we, as students of the dismal science, have faced.

One persecution I have faced for an argument I could never win, nor any economist ever could, is one on the benefits of sweatshops.

I have only dared to make this argument a few times, and have quickly been silenced by my own sense of guilt and social norms. Yet, anyone who has taken an Intro to Development Economics course knows how the pro-sweatshops argument goes:

Third World countries have a comparative advantage in cheap labor. People in Third World countries need money, and any job is better than no job. Work will be hard, but money start to flow in to the economy and eventually the working conditions will get better. Then same thing happened in the US.

And the counter-argument:

Sweatshops are forced on to people, and the capital injection that they provide are only temporary, as many transnational corporations will pick up and leave when the wages get too high.

And on, and on...

An op-ed piece in the NYT today tallied up one point for the sweatshops. It was written by Dana Thomas, taken from her new book "Deluxe: How Luxury Lost Its Luster," which I am very excited to read, as soon as it comes out in paperback. The op-ed was about the dirty deeds behind counterfeit purses, and it narrated her going and freeing young children in China from sweatshops manufacturing fake purses.

She said that as she left, these children "threw bottles and cans at us. They were now jobless and, because the factory owner housed them, homeless." Sweatshops are in no way sustainable, but this glimpse into one shows that a solution to sweatshop labor is not as easy as shutting them all down.

Another NYT's piece reported yesterday that wages in China (seemingly the poster-child for sweatshop labor, if you want to call it that) have increased by a significant amount in the past few months, in some cases almost doubling. Employers are having a difficult time finding employable people willing to work the hours and at the pace their "factories" require, causing wages to rise. Another point for sweatshops. (To be fair, Thomas mentioned that counterfeit-purse-factory workers make less than half of what normal sweatshop workers make.)

As I said before, sweatshops are in no way sustainable. I do not even think, at the level they are operating currently, they are a stepping stone to bigger and better things for Third World countries. But when reading about those children that threw bottles at their supposed "liberators", I remembered that stopping sweatshops and all the evils they impose is not as easy as knowing where your shirt came from. You need to know why it came from there, why you paid what you did, and what happens if you don't buy a shirt from there again.


Note: Check out this op-ed from Grinnell's own S&B, by the professor I mentioned in the beginning of this post, to hear some more arguments for sweatshops. (You have to get the bottom half first.)

Monday, August 27, 2007

What do foreheads and cars have in common?

I have always been fascinated by advertisements. I remember watching TV once with a friend, and I found myself yelling at the commercials for being stupid and pointless. My friend turned to me and said; "If you're going to get frustrated at every ad you see, you'll be in big trouble."

This morning's NYT proved his point. There was an article in the Media & Advertising section called "Your Ad Here, on MY S.U.V.? And You'll Pay?" It was about how businesses are beginning to pay ordinary people to drive around with ads on their cars. It reminded me of the person who auctioned off his forehead for tattoo-ad space.

Apparently, these forehead-billboards are not uncommon (type in "ad tattoos" to Google, and you'll see what I mean.) And, apparently, these car-billboards are not uncommon either. The article reports ten of thousands of people have participated in this form of advertisement, called "car wrapping". Companies offer an $800 stipend for this service, so getting a new paint job in the name of marketing is hard to refuse.

I can understand why a company would place their ad on an everyday car, the NYT reports that a single "car wrap" will be seen 70,000 times a day. And I know companies are looking for unique advertising space, especially since the invention of Tivo and satellite radio.

But I am reminded of the concluding comments of Malcolm Gladwell in The Tipping Point. He talked of "ad saturation", the concept that at some point, people can become saturated with ads and begin to ignore them completely. He argues that this "tipping point" for advertisements has already occur, and creating more ads, for any product, will only decrease the incentive to buy.

Obviously, the people paying to wrap a car with their product's message do not think this is the case. Back before the average American saw more than 600 ads in a day, more advertisements meant more exposure. If someone saw a Coke commercial on the six o'clock news in the Sixties, that might influence their next decision to buy a beverage. Now, seeing a Coke ad is a part of everyday life. It doesn't sway my decision one way or the other, and I would doubt if it did for anyone else.

When learning about classical conditioning in Intro to Psych, our professor explained that most marketers do not take into account human psychology when designing ads. As I begin to see more and more ads every day, and get more and more frustrated, I have to believe he is right.

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

Being un-American

Yesterday I remarked to my friend that this past summer I've slowly turned into a Socialist. I may or may not have been kidding, I still haven't decided, but one thing I am sure of is that I fully support universal health care for this country, and all countries.

That's why I was infuriated to read the today's NYT article, "Many Eligible for Child Health Plan Have No Idea." It reported on the fact that 1.7 million children that have qualified for the State Children's Health Insurance Program are not enrolled and are unaware of their eligibility. This is a disturbing figure, but what I found more disturbing were the small tidbits of information dropped into the article about the Bush administration's attitude towards expanded health care coverage.

Last week, the article says, the administration set new standards to discourage the expansion of state-run health care to children of middle-class families. Bush has threatened to veto bills in the House and the Senate that add billions of dollars into health care coverage of children because both are a "major step toward nationalized health coverage." The administration's main reason against this funding increase is that
the expansion...would transform the program into a broad entitlement. Many families, they predict, would cancel private insurance in favor of government coverage (one study found that 14 percent of enrollees did).

It seems like Bush is forgetting that the president should keep his or her citizens' best interests in mind. If people prefer universal health care, then the president should deliver universal health care. Bush, and many others in Washington, have politicized health care, making it "un-Republican" and "un-American" to want universal coverage. Most people realize there is a health crises in this country. It is just too bad those enlightened people don't run it.

Saturday, August 18, 2007

We're Missing Out

I remember a conversation in my intro Sociology class about a year and a half ago. We had just read an article about the AIDS epidemic in Africa (Time, Feb 2001). We were discussing AIDS as a social epidemic, rather than just a medical one. Someone mentioned that African people would never be able to emerge as a competitive group in the global economy, because they are are plagued by so many social, economic and medical problems.

I responded to this comment with a blindly optimistic rebuttal, saying that Africa will not only become a major trading partner in our lifetime, but that the US should begin to invest in Africa before missing out on this opportunity. Africa as a continent has great potential for economic growth. The US can benefit from African consumers, just as Africans can benefit from our investments. I've always thought Africans would soon emerge as a powerful consumer base and that the US should figure out a way to capitalize on this inevitable trend while there still is time.

Today, I learned that we might already be too late. Or, at least, behind the times. Not surprisingly, the country to beat us to this was China. Today's New York Time exposé, "Entrepreneurs From China Flourish in Africa", profiles several Chinese entrepreneurs seeking out their fortunes abroad. What makes these business people different from other ex-patriots is that they travel to Africa, instead of Western nations.

China is not the only country taking the African consumer seriously. Since 1955, there has been a strong relationship between African and Sino countries. (See the Bandung Conference.) South-south linkages, as they are commonly called, might be the only hope to lift Africa out of the quagmire it is in. What is so great about these south-south trade relations is that not only to Africans benefit from capital injection, but its done on economic turns, not as a handout.

I am not suggesting that we all leave to start businesses in African nations. I am not even suggesting that all Africa needs is foreign capital and investment. All I am saying is that this migration of Chinese is just illustrative of a larger trend. China, as well as other industrializing countries, sees Africa as an investment, not as a charity case. The more I learn about US-Africa relations (or even Western-African relations), the more disappointed I become. It is a shame the US is missing out on another great opportunity.